If you haven't noticed, this blog has become increasingly Lutheran, in the sense that I am increasingly airing my thoughts on theology and the church. I find these matters highly interesting and relevant, and I hope you all (whoever you are) understand that these are simply the musings of a young enthusiastic layperson.
one more caveat: this particular post is simply something that has occurred to me recently, and my examples are simply an attempt to prove my point, not an attempt to air dirty laundry or gripe about things per se. (Although, what are blogs for, if not to rant?)
OK, labels. My thesis is that many people within the LCMS use labels on themselves and others which have the effect of minimizing theological debate and marginalizing the contributions of theologically interested clergy and laypersons. Furthermore, this labeling trend points to an overall unwillingness to acknowledge theological deficiencies and disagreements within the LCMS as a whole, and within particular congregations.
Exhibit A: the most recent LCMS synodical convention. I have been reading Pr. Stuckwisch's lengthy accounts from that week since the convention began. Then yesterday, I read Peter Speckhard's shorter summary of the convention. Speckhard clarified what Stuckwisch's account seemed to suggest; a general unwillingness on the part of the synod leadership to acknowledge theological variance within the church body. This came out the most vividly during the discussion of "contemporary" worship practices. Speckhard relates that
"At one point it became almost comical (you can read about it on the online forum). A conservative speaker from the floor proposed an amendment to a resolution on worship asking that we recognize and work on our theological differences concerning worship, but when the recording secretary read the proposal back to the assembly before the vote, the word “theological” was missing.
"Whether intentional or not, the omission illustrates the problem. The opposition wants to discuss doctrine, but the majority under President Kieschnick do not see any of the disagreements as theological or doctrinal, but merely practical. As long as the discussion remains in the realm of practice, anything goes. After all, we’re allowed to do things differently as long as we confess the same faith."
This to me strikingly illustrates the discomfort that Lutherans feel in possibly disagreeing or differing from each other. It is better to simply omit discussion or debate than to discover variance or error within the church.
Exhibit B: my personal experience from my own family. Let me just say that my husband is an above-average layperson in terms of higher education and theological interests. As a layperson, he has been involved in leadership in our current congregation, and he has also attended a number of church and seminary conferences on theology and worship.
In his daily life, my husband has many unexpected opportunities to witness his faith to others. His education and reading helps him to better express his views clearly to Lutherans and non-Lutherans. We're not talking about Ablaze! moments here, but simply conversations with friends, colleagues, students, etc. (and of course his wife).
However, my husband is already labeled: "prospective seminarian."Supposing he goes to seminary, he will immediately be labeled "high church" and "conservative". Again, pushing him out of the mainstream and into a group which is seen as highly preferential and exclusive. He is expected at any time to launch into jargon-filled rants that would intimidate and confuse the average church goer. Of course, he (and I) do sometimes say things that are arrogant and overly enthusiastic and sometimes just mistakenly wrong. Well, look at me now! But having this special label attached makes those faults oh so visible and dangerous to "normal" Lutherans.
It seems as though, in the LCMS, only clergy are allowed to have deep theological learning, and those clergy who are most interested in matters of liturgy and theology are marginalized as belonging to those select few congregations that want that sort of thing. For the general masses, the shallower, the better. For non-ordained positions in LCMS-land, theological conviction is seen as a rare attribute that is less-than-relevant to the task at hand and that will probably make that person more difficult to work with.
Again, one illustration: last summer, my husband took two interviews. One was for music director in an LCMS church ( leading worship). The other was for an applied music teacher at a Wesleyan university (teaching instrumental playing). Guess which organization spent hours asking him detailed theological questions. Guess which organization hired him as being the best "mission fit" for the job at hand. Guess where he now spends his time leading in prayer, discussing theology, and counseling others. This is not to say that he should have been hired for the one job rather than the other; there were certainly other skills being considered. The current music director in this church is definitely quite qualified!
But based on the theological aspect of the interview and selection process, his theological convictions were seen as more important to teaching scales and etudes to Wesleyans than to selecting music for the Divine Service for Lutherans. The Wesleyans seem to realize the importance of faith and vocation, for laypeople, even more so than we Lutherans (steeped in Veith at that!).
In conclusion, by labeling theologically-educated or interested laypeople as "prospective seminarians," our church is minimizing their role as laypeople. This especially hurts the women, who are not "prospective seminarians" and often not in a position to become "deaconesses" either (although the pastors-wife-club is always open to us as perhaps the MOST marginalized group ever). Of course, it is best to discuss these matters at home with our husbands, but if our churches were more interested in educating laypeople in general, oh, the good we could all do, married or single, male or female, in our family and worldly vocations.
I hope that this blog has not offended anyone---I am using this blog as an unauthorized, unofficial forum of general discussion and free observation. I am definitely not an authority on the church, and have no political agenda here. I will probably conclude in about 45 minutes from now that I have overstepped my bounds and come back to heavily re-edit what I have written. But I see this as a serious issue, and one that needs to come out in the open. Tell me, those of you who have actually read this post to the end, that I am being paranoid and arrogant.
Wednesday, September 19, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I'm not going to tell you that you're being paranoid or arrogant (although what's a Lutheran without a little arrogance?).
I'm not sure these labels help matters either. I just think that most people use labels because humans have a need to organize things in their brains and that's one of the simplest ways to do it. It's easy to get too caught up in labeling though and miss the part where we are talking about real people with real ideas. That's the problem I think you are addressing and I think it's definitely worth talking about.
Well, and labels are not necessarily fanciful in their derivation. My husband does talk about the seminary. But the label "Prospective seminarian" is, I think, silly, and distracts people from their current vocation. To be interested in theology and the church, even to consider pursuing an M.Div., is far far away from being called as a pastor. And the things that are supposed to differentiate him from "normal" Lutheran laypeople actually help him in his current (lay) vocation.
Post a Comment