David van Biema's article in TIME last week has been bothering me every time I enter my bathroom (in case you didn't read my last post, TIME has become bathroom-reading material).
The most obvious shocker to me is that this book on Mother Teresa's spiritual life and lack thereof is being published by sources within her own church, within her own order, in fact by the person who is responsible for her sainthood-in-progress (her postulator, Rev. Brian Kolodiejchuk). Basically, an ordained priest in the Catholic church has published a lifetime of letters to Mother Teresa's spiritual superiors, advisers, and confessors. Against her explicit wishes, her church is publishing her confessions.
That her inner struggles are being aired for the world to read (in their bathrooms, remember?) is not so much the problem as that this is no Augustinian autobiography---this is material from her confessors. If Mother Teresa can't expect confidentiality from her spiritual authorities, how can anyone else truly trust this church body either?
Here are a couple thoughts on why this has happened (and oh, how inappropriate it all is), with the caveat that I am not completely equipped with time or theological training to do more than rant:
1) These letters are not true confessions of sin. Teresa is lamenting her feelings of abandonment and doubt and lack of faith, but since she was outwardly carrying out works of piety and mercy, she was not really sinful. Therefore, these letters are interesting, but not bound to the confidentiality requirements had she actually been a sinner in confession.
Again, I'm basing this all on TIME's summary, so this analysis may not apply (she may also have been going to confession, besides writing these particular letters). It is not my argument that Teresa was sinning in some specific way, because that is not my call to make. However, if she were seeking refuge for a troubled conscience, how inappropriate to print that in public, as though to deny that her sins are forgiven by Christ (who uses his ministers in the holy office of confession and absolution).
2) Her spiritual struggles were in themselves good works. The article, in summary of the book, concludes that Teresa's "darkness" was eventually accepted by her as a way to share in Christ's Passion. Her confessor Rev. Joseph Neuner told her
"the three things she needed to hear: that there was no human remedy for it (that is, she should not feel responsible for affecting it); that feeling Jesus is not the only proof of his being there, and her very craving for God was a "sure sign" of his "hidden presence" in her life; and that the absence was in fact part of the "spiritual side" of her work for Jesus."
The first few thoughts there seem fine, but the phrase "work for Jesus" is really quite perverse, as though it is comforting to know that we can chip in and help Jesus out. This whole crisis---and I am not downplaying the importance of what Teresa was experiencing, nor how devastating it must have been---seems somewhat overly self-centered. Yes, sin and doubt are the trials that affect us deeply here on earth, but we should not enshrine our own failings simply because we cannot escape them. Christ works through us despite our sinful flesh. Mother Teresa is genuinely upset at not being a good enough Christian, so she is offered the comforting thought that yes, her contributions are good enough. Christ died for us so that we can pay him back with, well, whatever we got to offer.
3) Mother Teresa seems to have shown a need for self-sacrifice, not only on a daily vocational level, but on the order of achieving justification before God, to the weird extent that she would deny herself heaven in order to be a saint. (!?) Van Biema writes:
""If I ever become a Saint — I will surely be one of 'darkness.' I will continually be absent from Heaven — to [light] the light of those in darkness on earth," she wrote in 1962. Theologically,this is a bit odd since most orthodox Christianity defines heaven as God's eternal presence and doesn't really provide for regular no-shows at the heavenly feast. But it is, Kolodiejchuk suggests, her most moving statement, since the sacrifice involved is infinite. "When she wrote, 'I am willing to suffer ... for all eternity, if this [is] possible,'" he says, "I said, Wow.""
Oh, the heresy of it all. Forget that this person is well on her way to canonization. How did she become a nun---for what use were the years of training in the church, of service in holy orders, of spiritual supervision and advice from her pastors and confessors---if at the end, she is seeking her own "infinite sacrifice" for salvation?
I know that my protests seem quite negative and harsh. I know that there are good and helpful lessons to be learned from reading this book. I wish I could articulate this all better, but. . .. Let me say in conclusion that I firmly believe that the theological problems Mother Teresa experienced are the basic problems of the Roman Catholic church in the 20th century. I do not question her trials and discouragement; what truly bothers me is that her church may have made her sufferings worse through doctrinal errors, leading her through years of darkness and despair. Publishing these letters now seems only another way in which they have let her down.
Wednesday, September 05, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this, Emily. I think you are quite insightful in your remarks.
I was likewise troubled, in particular, by the fact that her confidential confessions have been divulged to anyone. The fact that she is now dead is irrelevant. As you point out, others will be less inclined to confess at all, out of fear that what they say will not be kept confidential.
Any priest or pastor that breaks the seal of the confessional ought to be removed from office immediately, and needs to go to confession himself for such a grave sin.
I don't know. It's possible that some of her thoughts are completely out of context. Surely, there are many other Christians out there who have wished that they could actually bring others to salvation through their own sacrifice. I mean, even the apostle Paul said something to that effect. Maybe Mother Theresa even knew that it was a vain hope.
I think there isn't much way of knowing as these were her private confessions. It's too bad she did not write her own book really. It's kind of like reading someone's diary in this case. We all say the oddest things in the diary that we know no one else will read. Yes, I agree that no one should have published her confessions like that.
Esther is right; I could be over-reacting to letters that are personal, but not meant to be---strictly---confessional. TIME suggested the latter, but I don't know if van Beima knows the difference. I do know that a) she didn't want them to be published; and b) she seemed to be looking for comfort in all the wrong places, namely in what she could contribute to God.
I tried to say in my post that what bothered me was not the anguish she felt, which I understand, but the misunderstanding that led her to seek grace with God through her own feelings and efforts rather than in the Cross. As I understand, this error is the foundation of Roman "sainthood": that this person has achieved an excess of righteousness or "grace" in her life, which is now available to others. How much better to accept that we are poor, miserable sinners who can do nothing to save ourselves.
Pastor Esget's sermon on the ten lepers, which I will reference in my next post, has some amazingly appropriate remarks for this theme of despair and abandonment.
Post a Comment