Saturday, January 31, 2009

Questions about Octuplets

The birth of octuplets in California have been causing a steady stream of media furor. Here are my questions about the blessed event:

1. What happened to a woman's right to choose what she does with her own body?

2. Why is it considered obsessive for one woman to have 14 children (well, 8 at a time is the big thing here) but normal for a doctor to make 14 embryos at a time for one woman?

3. Did this woman's doctor talk through the complete scenario before beginning the IVF process? In other words, did he know that a) she would try to give birth to every embryo created and b) if implanted with multiples, she would carry the full number that survived to term? If he did, then how was this situation not an abuse of trust (by putting her and the babies in a life-threatening situation) and if he didn't, again, what were his assumptions?

4. Is there not an assumption here that embryos may be created without the intention to give them life? In fact, if they are not given the chance to grow and be born, are they not destined to be destroyed? And how is that ethically sound? After all, the whole incredible promise of embryonic stem cell research is the power of the cells at the very beginning of life. To use that power requires the taking of life, no matter how early or unformed.

5. Is there not a sense, from the standpoint of honoring individual rights and preserving life, that this crazy woman was the only responsible person in the room---or in the state---or in the country? And doesn't that imply that the entire fertility process might be ethically flawed?

No comments: