Wednesday, May 21, 2014

The Ugly Duckling Gets Angry

I have always thought of myself as an ugly duckling.  The thought helps my self-esteem. . . it gives me a sense of accomplishment and even, to my mind, makes up for the pain and suffering of my adolescent and teenage years.  Just like when you delete all the unflattering photos from your camera, and publish the pretty ones, I can "erase" all the years of seeing and being seen as an awkward, poorly dressed teenager who didn't pluck her eyebrows, who wore frumpy clothes, and had no idea what to do with my hair.  Every time I fix up my makeup, lose weight, wear nice clothes, or have a good hair day, I am preserving my current swan status in the world.  I really hope that other girls don't envy me---if they knew where I came from, they would understand that I am working just as hard as they are to please with my appearance.  Everyone loves beauty.  I'm doing the world a service by my careful attention to looking pretty.

Of course, that whole paragraph is BS!

Just as women everywhere are protesting the airbrushed images of female beauty, and trying, despite their ingrained beliefs, to believe that pretty is not measured in inches, I am finding out that the counter-culture of "purity" given me by the Christian evangelical world was also lying to me.  By pulling Bible verses about modesty and chastity out of context, I was taught that my sexual maturity spelled the end of physical confidence and self-acceptance.  Beauty leads to desire, and desire leads to sin, and sin leads to lifelong contamination.  If I didn't save my sexuality for my future husband, but instead showed it to one and all, I was headed straight for fornication, which would of course rob my marriage of sexual completeness forever.  Not that this female purity myth was invented in 1982!  Just read Tess of the D'Urbevilles (appropriately subtitled: "A Pure Woman").

So, I was taught, by pop-Christianity and homeschool cults alike, that "purity" meant hiding and running from the opposite sex, or at the most, interacting in cool neutrality with boys. Of course, a good Christian boy would know to avoid me, the Emily full of passionate desires, uncontrolled speech, and wild ideas.

Up until now, I've been in denial I was hurt and am still deeply hurt by this culture, forced upon me by my so well-intentioned parents and friends.  Instead, I have tried to package those terrible years as having been deserved by my lack of social skills, decent clothing, and personal grooming.  There is a satisfaction in being an ugly duckling.  I may have been ugly and awkward then, but least I went to college and made my own choices.  And I sort of succeeded in finding sexual attractiveness and self-worth.  I can hardly believe it, but in my sophomore year, I made it into the saxophone studio's "hot list!"  In a way, this accomplishment was worth more than, say, my 4.0 college transcript, or performing an entire Bach sonata from memory. I wish I could put it on my resume.

But now, when I finally read articles like this one, and this one, the "aha" sets in. Believe me, I did my best to forget and repress my experiences.  (My husband is saying "finally!")  Facing them down makes me MAD.  Give me a lie from "Seventeen" or any other checkout-line magazine, and I can confront it, mock it, reject it if I want to (sometimes I don't).  Give me a lie in the name of HOLINESS?  That still cripples my whole generation of Christian sisters?  These people deserve a millstone around their necks. I feel especially sorry for the many homeschoolers that bought into this "godly character" cult and offered up their girls as an offering to predators. That's (I hope) an extreme example, but I wish all my friends (like, all my friends growing up) who were in that program would have known then the terrible results of this "godliness" on their children.

Was I really an "ugly duckling?"  Am I a "swan" now?  Ha. . . what if, all this time, I was beautiful and complete in my sexuality (you have no idea how hard it was for me to type that word), and have nothing to be ashamed of?

If I could say one thing to my friends and family, it is this.  You HAVE been hurt.  Not only anorexic models have distorted body images.  Bad teaching is also ABUSE.  Be angry. Find a good counselor who can call it like it is. Facing the truth takes courage, and it is going to hurt. But take comfort: you are pure and complete in Jesus, ALWAYS have been and will be, and nothing you have thought or done can take away one bit of your completeness.  And you know what?  If you are a male "purity" victim or love a woman who has gone through this, you get to go through the same process of grief and healing. Do it. The truth will set you free.

No comments: