Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

More Jane Austen

This post is dedicated to Esther, whose post about the superior representation of the really really long Pride and Prejudice movie sparked all kinds of thoughts about what a great novel Pride and Prejudice is, and how my beloved 2005 version of the book lacks depth and subtlety. In honor of her discussion of these amazing characters and what makes them tick, and to redeem myself from the shallow idolatry I have been paying to Mr. Darcy in my previous post, I would like to write my most recent thoughts about this great work and wonderful characters. I will group them by characters:

Elizabeth Bennet: this is Jane Austen's strongest and most compelling heroine. I would argue that she is a proto-feminist ideal: self-determined, outspoken, not dependent on convention, money, or men, lives by her own reason and superior female intuitions. Although she is commonly understood to represent "Prejudice" in the novel, she has a very clear view of the world and articulates quite well the distinction between herself and the "elegant females" around her. She is in some ways, idealistic and naive for being bamboozled by Wickham, as though a military man is expected not to embellish his character and history to gain female attention. She is also quite resentful of the class/societal distinctions that Mr. Darcy and his noble relatives represent. Although she is right that her rank as a gentleman's daughter is equal to his, and that in any case she deserves civility and respect from the man who loves her, I think that by the end of the book she realizes that he is quite correct in his analysis of her family situation, if not in his manners. Like the stereotypical feminist, she learns to fear being left, at the end, quite alone, and becomes grateful to Mr. Darcy for not giving up on her. She also recognizes true love, which looks somewhat different than she expected.

Jane Bennet: this is the typical "elegant female" who does in fact have the "false modesty" Mr. Collins has learned to expect. She meekly and willingly takes crap from Mr. Bingley and his sister, and would not have pursued Mr. Bingley at all (the unfruitful London trip) if not for Elizabeth's urging (the proto-feminist). She is quite in love, and not at all happy at being discarded thanks to Bingley's lack of self-agency. However, by being the pliant and agreeable young lady she is, there is nothing really left to do but sit at home and wait. This situation is anathema to Lizzie, whose outgoing spirits eke out proposals left and right, and who finds herself touring Mr. Darcy's estate before she has really considered his offer. Jane is just as proper, dignified, and intelligent, but is always in a fairly weak position with the opposite sex.

Mr. Wickham: he has such a tenuous grasp on gentility, that it is quite silly to find him so familiar with the Bennet family. When we first meet him, he is not a commissioned officer, he is the son of a high-ranking servant, and has lost the good will of the one friend whose society would elevate Wickham, by association, to the rank wherein the Bennets reside. Thus, he is desperately searching for elevation by marriage to a very young (his penchant for 15-year-olds would be absolutely criminal today) and gullible woman. He recognizes Elizabeth's superiority, and while he uses her to pass off his fake credentials of good character and respectability, he cannot get too close. By marrying Lydia, he secured both rank and security---this is a woman whom he can control and who will never understand his true (scummy) character.

Mr. Darcy: the Matthew Mcfayden character is definitely a romantic version of Jane Austen's original. By providing Darcy with social anxiety disorder, the movie makers have endeared him to the hearts of their female viewers as a misunderstood but definitely humbler and gentler hero.

I prefer to understand Darcy as someone who has been disappointed in friendship, threatened by the loss of his nearest and dearest (death of parents, sister nearly running away), and generally disillusioned by ridiculous relatives, and weak (Bingley) and shallow (Miss Bingley) friends to whose society he submits from a general lack of good options. He distrusts people, and is depressed and unmotivated to get to know new people, especially when they are drooling over his massive fortune. His rudeness to the heroine is quite inexcusable of a gentleman, but somewhat understandable from someone who is used to being really, superior, amidst his companions. Knowing Elizabeth throws him off considerably; it's like his first major crush and he doesn't know what to do. So he spills his guts (with the perfect and complex sentence structure only a Jane Austen character uses in emotional crises). What is really lacking is a sense of what he looks like to other people (I wish I knew what that word is I'm looking for).

In his eyes, he is quite correct, and technically, he is right about Elizabeth and her family and Wickham and Jane. But like a typical man, he doesn't understand that the technically true analysis of things is usually not the best thing to blurt out, especially in marriage proposals. He thinks he is doing Elizabeth a favor by offering her love: her role in society is to marry for necessity, not emotional fulfillment. As ridiculous and offensive as his proposal is, he does understand her, and her desire for emotional and intellectual reciprocity. This is a new and rare thing and not typical of the "elegant female" of the time. And it does, eventually, sway Elizabeth and lead her towards a greater sympathy, understanding, and eventually, love for our hero. Meanwhile, her quick-witted and well-deserved response teaches and tames him and primes the nascent relationship for greater depth of understanding and respect.

I would like to write a book about Elizabeth Bennet and her sisters; I feel that each sister represents a different ideal of womanhood popular at the time. Had I followed my mother's advice and gone into English rather than music, I could be writing a dissertation on this instead of playing violin poorly. At any rate, I hope someone out there enjoys reading this post as much as I enjoyed writing it. Thanks, Esther!