My family recently watched The Queen (2006) with Helen Mirren. This movie, while not my favorite ever, is definitely in my favorite movie genre---that is, the genre in which movies consist only of conversations between polite, well-educated British persons.
So, with this great appeal, it has naturally dominated my thoughts ever since. I was out of it ten years ago when Princess Diana died, so I have no idea how literally true everything is, but it rang true for me in all the ways I expect a good work of drama to be "true". I found all the characters compelling, and truly identified with their perspective, emotions, and responses (except for Prince Phillip, who was just appalling, sorry.) So this is more a response to these people as characters in a movie than their real-life counterparts.
I most identified with two characters: Cherie Blair, like myself, is a strong out-spoken woman married to a strong man in a prominent leadership position. Like me, she tells her husband exactly what she thinks should be done, knowing that it's his decision and he will jolly well do what he thinks he should. But what else is an opinionated wife to do? She is privileged to be in on some momentous events, and she reacts accordingly (and she makes her husband clean up his dishes! I loved that bit.)
I really identify with her: it's hard to watch the stress and difficult decisions that one's husband has to make in his work without having something to say about it all. But, once your husband is in this public role, you can't very well talk about all this with any one else.
Questions of propriety lead me naturally to identify with the Queen. At first, I thought she was sort of cold and either uncaring or completely oblivious. As I went along though, I realized that I do share the same value preferences for order, stability, and tradition, over against the "modernizing" values expressed by Blair and his cohorts. The old aristocracy of birth, rank, education, and honor which Queen Elizabeth II represents has been replaced by a new aristocracy of fame/notoriety, wealth, and celebrity, represented by Diana. This new aristocracy engages the imagination, emotions, and loyalty of the masses.
The Queen, being herself intelligent, devoted, loyal and optimistic, fails to realize that her people are much less intelligent or loyal to the crown than they once were, and are much more susceptible to guidance by tabloids and celebrities than by their sworn and devoted public leaders. At first I was appalled by the Queen's lack of sympathy with the people---by the end of the movie, I was appalled by the people's lack of sympathy with the Queen. The Queen is acting properly, following precedent, upholding the protocol and dignity of her office, and she is sharply criticized for doing so.
This leads me to the following conclusion. As much as I adore etiquette, protocol, and proper guidelines for my leadership roles and general behavior in public, this is the sort of thing that people hate in their leaders. Following the "official" methods of decision making gives the masses absolutely nothing to read in the tabloids. They would much rather have a young, unmarried, anorectic/substance-addicted girl get pregnant so that they can spend nine months obsessing over "Is she pregnant?" "Her baby is in danger!" "Will she stay together with the baby's father?" "Will she go to jail?" But if a happily married, stable, middle-aged woman has her third child, the gossip magazines just get a little blip on the radar screen, "So-and-so had a baby."
People would much rather see their leaders behave inappropriately so that they have something to point their fingers at, and feel that they themselves might just do a better job with that power and wealth. The masses will never admit that they, the tabloid readership, are responsible for the demise of their favorite celebrities. They will swoon, gossip, drool over, and force them by aggressive techniques to commit more public improprieties, and then blame them for not being more individually responsible in their personal lives.
But what emerges from this movie is how the Queen's attention to behavior and etiquette is not a weakness, but a strength. She may have lost some ground with the affections of the people, but she remains an impeccable leader and untarnished public figure who will probably be remembered as the last great monarch of England.
No comments:
Post a Comment