Tuesday, July 17, 2007

Surprise! The Pope is Catholic.


By this, I mean "Roman Catholic" of course.

An interesting news article, again from TIME's website. If these links don't work from TIME archives, let me know.

I guess I should feel disappointed, since Pope Benedict XVI has said that I don't belong to a true church, and that my "ecclesial community" doesn't have the means of salvation. But the fact that this pronouncement is newsworthy means that some people weren't aware of this basic principle of Roman Catholicism. Probably, even some Roman Catholics are out there cringing at the pope's effort to clear up the compromise and "ecumenicism" (read: relativism) that pervades post-Vatican II Catholicism, especially in America. Using his office and public influence to restate the basic truths about RC doctrine is a good thing---it shows that he is not afraid of what the world thinks. He is trying to preserve the heritage he has been given. Ditto for the reinstatement of the Latin mass.

Obviously, I don't agree with this particular doctrine of papal primacy and apostolic succession, but it's important to know about, and my perception of Christendom at this time is that we are all suffering from doctrinal deprivation. Without a clear articulation of these important beliefs (whether orthodox or heretical), laypeople are left to drift in their own relativistic creations. The Pope reminds us that he knows the difference, and cares that his flock knows too. [N.B. For a more intelligent Lutheran discussion of this, see Pastor Stiegemeyer's blog ]

Bravo, Benedict, for "daring to be Roman!"

2 comments:

Esther said...

I don't care for Vatican II, but I really don't think it's a good thing that the Pope calls the rest of us un-Christian. Saying that he is open to "ecumenical dialogue" is utter nonsense.

For the record, I was a fan of Pope John Paul II because of his background and his influence in aiding the fall of communism. I think he was pretty hardcore when it comes to doctrine, but he had a sense of mercy about him that the current Pope just doesn't have. I don't think it's new for the Pope to be a hardliner on doctrinal issues. John Paul II rather openly disagreed with Vatican II from what I understood. It would be a new thing if the rest of the Catholics became more like the Pope on this stuff.

That's a good point on the articulation of doctrine. It is rather wanting in today's society.

Emily said...

True, I should be careful that I may have implied something I don't know or mean. (hit edit button) I appreciate the current pope's courage to speak the truth about his church in a relativistic age. But myself not being a relativist, it is silly to applaud the actual beliefs with with I don't agree.