Think of it from my (imaginary) standpoint (I am avoiding real situations as it is not the purpose of my blog to foist unwelcome confessions upon the general public).
I have been through (let’s say) bulimia, and found it to be a life-changing traumatic experience, one that I now see as having been quite threatening, and one that opened my eyes to the existence and impact of a devastating physical and psychological phenomena which many other people experience as well. After having passed through such an experience, I feel a level of insight and enlightenment on the topic which I did not previously possess. This feeling of insight is in itself a type of knowledge generally known as “Experience,” a term now popularized by Hillary Clinton.
How is this knowledge to be shared? Might not my insights be more valuable than those of the general non-bulimic public? Am I wrong in feeling that I have something to offer to someone who may be at danger of falling into this disorder, or who needs help in overcoming or understanding a current crisis?
Furthermore, although my testimony would not be admissible in a court of law as proof of the nature of a bulimic person’s actions (I having no scientific credentials as an “expert witness”, and assuming that the trial is not about my own actions), does not a court of law serve a more specific immediate purpose as to determining the truth of an actual event (crime)? And since I feel I have a more transcendent Experience to offer, might it not be relevant to a more overarching discussion as to the nature of eating disorders?
Let me suggest a few fields in which testimonial evidence is generally used and accepted.
- The press. Newspapers and magazines often run feature articles on the experience of one or more individuals to highlight a problem or trend in the general public.
- Literature. Novels are written by individuals on the basis of their own life experiences and observations, and yet found, on their literary merits, to be persuasive of human nature as a whole.
- Commercial sales. I know that it is quite suspect to use a form of evidence for the purpose of making money, but seeing that clean swath of carpet on the commercial makes you want to own a good vacuum. Vendors recognize that we make decisions based on personal experience of results, and so they use testimonies and reenacted scenarios on commercials to substitute for personal experience of positive results. If even Jessica Simpson used to be ugly before she used this acne cream, think about how it might help you.
- Political campaigns. In which politicians whip out hard-off individuals living under the current government and prove the need for change based on the dire straits of present day living.
Although, some of these categories may seem disreputable, we have all at one time or another used them to make important decisions. Even my esteemed lecturer from the first paragraph highly recommended the reading of literary works as a means towards witnessing about the Christian faith. And he greatly scorned the “personal testimony” as a witnessing tool. Unless, it seems, C.S. Lewis wrote it. I admit, C.S. Lewis had much better reasons to believe than most of us are able to come up with. But does not the act of religious conversion constitute a moving, life-changing, major life experience that one is naturally eager to share?
In conclusion, I am not arguing that one should defend the Christian faith on the basis of personal testimony alone. However, I suggest that our personality and perceptions are overwhelmingly shaped by our personal experience, and that we are simply being honest by disclosing those experiences as a prelude to explaining our beliefs about what is true. In addition, since the general public is so used to hearing testimonial evidence about a number of topics, I suggest that one’s “testimony” can be persuasive on a level which would not otherwise be addressed by general evidence on a topic.
1 comment:
Thanks for the thought provoking post.
I wonder if the problem of a "testimonial" type defense of the Gospel is that the premise of the testimonial is wrong. More often than not when testimonials start to fly, decision theology is not far behind. This, obviously, is erroneous Christianity. Ultimately, this type of testimonial depends upon the individual to pull themselves up by their bootstraps and decide to take Jesus into their hearts. The quality of this kind of "testimonial" could be likened to my quality of knowledge in menstrual pains. I may experience cramps and bloating from time to time, yet I am still unqualified to speak on the discomfort of a woman's menstruation.
A "testimonial" from a truly Christian perspective is of a different type. This kind of testimonial focuses on Christ's work which is credited to us. I think these personal stories of conversion cut to the heart of the Gospel. I believe this is important in the process of conversation with an unbeliever. However, the point is that we don’t focus on our role in the conversion. We point directly to Christ’s role. If I am to be prepared to give an account of the hope that is within me, people must first know my hope. I believe this is why we were taught that the Gospel should be presented to the unbeliever first and foremost.
Here is what I am getting at.
P1: We live by experiences as human beings.
P2: Sharing a testimonial of our experiences serves two purposes: 1) The conveying of personal emotions to another person due to an experience. 2) The conveying of knowledge obtained through an experience to another person.
P3: Both of these functions can exist in the same testimonial.
P4: Both functions can be erroneously or mischievously used.
P5: Factual evidence is used to determine matters of truth.
C: Testimonials should be an accurate portrayal of emotions and knowledge. A testimonial should be examined under the facts of the field being spoken of in it. When testimonials are accurate (in both functions), it will serve a good purpose. When one of the functions is erroneous the testimonial should be discarded pending correction.
All of this is kind of “off the cuff” as they say. I wanted to throw it out there and see what it stirs up. Thanks again for the thoughtful post.
Post a Comment