Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Now leaving the theological minefield, and entering the mission field, albeit missing a few limbs.

In which I present a personal testimony of an LCMS church on the other side of the tracks. If the LCMS were as unified as our president thinks it to be (in his dreams), your church might look like this in a few years. This church seemed very friendly, populous, and solvent, too!

However, not counting the many wonderful confessional churches in our Synod, which have no apparent relationship to this congregations other than four letters on their church billboards. . . here is a picture of the LCMS Ablaze!tm.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

One month ago, we visited a thriving LCMS congregation in a suburb of Cleveland. We made it in the door just as the procession was forming, led by a young (girl) acolyte, holding an unlit brass candlelighter, followed by four or five clerical-looking men and women, all dressed, like the acolyte, in albs, cinctures, and pectoral crosses. One person seemed to be in charge, for he gave the opening collect(spontaneously composed) at the beginning of the procession, followed by announcements from the front after the processional hymn, urging us to come vote in the primary on Tuesday and bring cookies for the bake sale. He then proceeded to offer corporate confession and absolution, slightly changing the words in one sentence at the end to omit the word "ordained".

Yet we were still confused as to this person's identity, as we then witnessed the Holy Baptism of an infant from the congregation by the same clergyperson. We began to read the worship folder compulsively, scanning for the morning's personnel list to assure ourselves that we were being given the sacraments by the ordained pastor of the church (did I mention that there were no stoles in sight?). We saw that we had, listed by date of service,

an Elder (male)
a Lay Reader (female)
a Eucharistic Lay Minister (female)
an Acolyte (female)

and on the front of the folder,
a Rev.
a Pastoral Assistant
a Vicar
as well as various Worship personnel who probably had more work on days with Contemporary Services, but who would manage to screw up the music selection regardless. (more later)

Surely it must be the Rev. who was offering the Sacraments this morning, since he had not introduced himself as a guest pastor. Perhaps his stole was at the cleaner's?

After the baptism, again with a few confusing rearrangements from the published order, but nothing too disturbing (the baby was definitely baptized, so that was good), we proceeded to omit all the other parts of the service and skip directly to the readings, read by the Lay Reader (OT and Epistle) and the Unidentified Clergyperson (the Gospel). The hymn of the day was replaced by "I Love to Tell the Story," which some random person with a microphone introduced, rather lengthily, as the soloist's gift of praise in response to a sermon preached by the vicar last week. The soloist, a sweet lady, sang her song, accompanied by a trio of men humming along during the chorus. The speakers were just behind my head, at least the really massive set was, and I thought that we were all supposed to be humming along. I almost did. Then everyone applauded, while I cowered and cringed. It is a habit I learned back in my youth when my fellow non-denominationalists were applauding my "special music".

We then were accosted by another clergyperson, who paced a narrow circuit mid-stage between the lectern and the pulpit. The large overhead screen changed from displaying the sermon title ("Blind") to an introductory PowerPoint slide complete with another attractive photo of something generically non-religious and stimulating of confused musings. This apparently was the sermon, and I understood that we were being addressed by the aforesaid vicar, who inspires great hymns about oneself and one's telling the mysterious "Story".

He began by praising the soloist's gift of music to us and declaring that no sermon was necessary after such an inspiring song. Apparently, the mission of this church's worship is to reinforce the contribution of its members. Not only are we vesting as many of them as we can get to serve at the altar, but we must make announcements as often as possible to highlight each other's talents and gifts to the church.

Then the vicar (how that term has fallen) began to preach a very long, confusing, spontaneous sermon, based loosely on a few verses from earlier in the chapter that our Gospel reading had been from. He tried to outline the chapter for us on PowerPoint, but quickly moved on to his real message----Keep It Simple, "Silly". Apparently, (and all the rest of my summary is based on my confused attempt at logical thought during this experience), like the blind man in the reading, we silly Lutherans cling to our Book of Concord but have not been enlightened by a true conversion experience. He concluded with a series of personal testimonies by people who had been truly saved, and then a PowerPoint slide with a picture of a globe. Once we experience the simplicity of true conversion, then we can spread the "Story" to the world.

Somewhere in the middle of this long derisive ramble, my young son became restless and I escaped to go play with nursery toys in their cry room, listen to the much sweeter music of infants crying for their mother's milk, and watch PowerPoint slides in stupefied amazement. My husband joined me during the offering (there was no Creed) and began to ask the other mothers who the presiding clergyperson was. They verified that he was, indeed, the Pastoral Assistant who was at that moment consecrating the elements for Holy Communion, and that no, he was not ordained. In fact, the congregation and their clergypersons had been told that their Pastoral Assistant must cease and desist his labors, and after much protest on the part of the congregation, he had been enrolled in an Alternate Route to ordination, and thus returned to his work without a qualm. Now, this Alternate Route is not exactly a University of Phoenix degree, being offered by an LCMS seminary, but it still puts our guy as being somewhat farther from actual ordination than our esteemed vicar, with all his superior education in the Lutheran faith.

So we decided that our son would continue to be too fussy and demanding to allow us to go in for communion that morning. After the conclusion of the sacrament, a few more spontaneous prayers, and a benediction from the presiding layperson (notice I have changed my term for him now), we read "The Worship has Ended. The Service Begins." on the final page of our service folder and left amid yard signs informing us that we were "Now Entering the Mission Field."


3 comments:

Esther said...

The really scary part was the sermon about "conversion" experiences. I found it comforting that the LCMS does not require conversion experiences. I mean, I never had one. I spent half my life thinking I wasn't really saved because people told me I had to have a conversion experience in order to receive salvation.

On a side note, the nondenominational, evangelical churches are actually suffering a bit from all the commercialism and hoopla they do. I find it confusing that the LCMS would want to enter an obviously failed movement. I mean, have you checked out the whole Emerging Church thing? It's been going on for a few years and is basically a backlash against evangelical protestantism which is -- frankly -- not very well thought out. Having grown up in an evangelical setting I understand having a backlash, however.

You have inspired me. Maybe I'll go write a lengthy post on religion now.

Emily said...

I have heard about something called the "emergent church movement" and not as a good thing, but I couldn't tell you more. Perhaps I should research this for my next post. . .

Emily said...

Also, the vicar's sermon conclusion was by no means as clear as I have presented it. It was unbelievably vague and suggestive, and seemed to focus more on how we should feel (guilty for being Lutheran? Happy for being saved? Well, you should listen to this random personal testimony on a PowerPoint slide).

What bothered me is that the sermons by vicars that I have heard are usually quite . . . green. They are unrefined, earnest, and as exegetically sound as the man can muster up. They are not nearly as confident and subversive as this particular vicar came out to be. He even dropped hints of his intellectual acumen at the Wednesday night Bible studies, and how many vicars can boast of those?

It is most likely that this congregation is coming up with all this modern evangelical heresy themselves, and that the vicar is an apt learner. But really, this service was led by two seminarians. As Professor Kirke said, "I wonder what they do teach them at these schools."