-->
Certain internet blogger-types (people I don’t know but who have prominent profiles) have been making snide/angry remarks over this picture from my church’s Good Friday service. The people making the remarks are people who are not members of our church, and were not present for Holy Week services here. These remarks are showing up as comments venting their anger on the blogs of other third-party bloggers (innocent parties, at that) who were also not present or involved with our church or services. As you can imagine, I’m a little ticked off. Since I have a relatively low blog profile, I’m hoping to spout off a little without drawing down the full wrath of the third party commenters.
One of the things that has come to grate upon me is the assertion used in these comments, “The purpose of the liturgy (or, ceremonies) is to teach.” I am not against explanation and catechesis, but this blanket assertion is being used in conjunction with a great deal of outrage and accusations of all kinds. My perspective on all of this outrage is that these people are not emotionally self-aware. Toward this end, I have adopted a new slogan: “The Purpose of This Ceremony is to Upset You.”
Let us rule out the possibility that our ceremonies are done for the purpose of appeasing an angry God. This is not a Christian belief. Christ has done everything for us on the cross. Thus the cross is visually, verbally, in every way emphasized in our liturgy and ceremonies. So any act of reverence is not done for God, but as a response to God’s gift of salvation.
What then, does a picture like this suggest? Humility, repentance, veneration, dependence, love, adoration. . . full-blown, no holds barred worship. Is this comfortable? Is this pleasant? It may turn out to be comforting to the soul, but to our human emotions, it is discomforting in the extreme. It is powerful, and it is scary. I was there, and those of us kneeling in the back corner didn’t even see it happen. Seeing the picture really shook me to the core. So I do sympathize, emotionally, with these commenters who are upset. But to take these emotions and rationalize them as some sort of just anger is not accurate, or effective, especially when augmented by mud-slinging.
If we say, by means of logical definition, “The purpose of this ceremony,” (here, prostration---you could also include other gestures like bowing, kneeling, or genuflecting, all humiliating postures for sure) “is to teach” we are able to limit and exclude the more –ahem—direct purposes of such ceremonies. How about “to reverence,” “to receive,” “to worship,” “to confess,”—and in non-theological language—“to humiliate the crap out of yourself?” Our pastor is a pretty direct type of leader. He doesn’t demonstrate ceremonies, he does them. Yes, he teaches us the how and why of our practices, he writes, hosts conferences, and is a pretty visible figure/target in the confessional-liturgical-conservative-Lutheran world (our church has been prominent in this field long before he arrived). But when it comes to the services, he just acts, he does, he receives, and he gives Christ to us.
So why bend your neck, or your knees, or your face down to the floor? Why go to a service and watch your pastor do it? To learn new ideas? To follow a well-respected or fully-accepted rubric from your branch of church history? To identify yourself with a particular branded concept or publication? That just seems so indirect in comparison to what this action actually does to the participant or observer. You bow to humiliate yourself, to confess that you are a sinner in need of mercy, to confess that you don’t understand or comprehend the fullness of God’s mercy to you in Christ, but that you need it and you take it anyway. The fact that we (as worshippers) do these humiliating gestures in front of crucifixes, or the altar, or our pastor as he blesses us, does not negate our worship of Christ but rather focuses and directs our weak minds and bodies to the reality of what is happening in the service, whether seen or unseen.
In my congregation, laypeople are not instructed how to fold our hands, how to bow, or how to do any of those ceremonies that may not be usual practice in other Lutheran churches. We are there, and we take what is given to us, and do what seems appropriate in freedom and reverence. By no means are our practices in the pews forced upon us, nor are they exactly uniform among us. And, yes, we are taught by what we see. But more than that, we are fed by God’s gifts of Word and Sacrament, and the ceremonies are an integrative part of that nourishment that cannot simply be defined as didactic, any more than a family dinner can be defined as dietetics.
No comments:
Post a Comment