My family and I had a recent run-in with several fellow parishioners who staged an impromptu "intervention" with us over our two-year-old's behavior in church. After crying for several hours (I was crying, not the two-year-old), and then seeking out some trusted advice. . . I made some important realizations.
First, as James Poniewozik wrote in Time, "to be a parent is less to be loved than to be judged," and small children are especially good at drawing attention in public. Even if my son always sat still in the pew (he almost never sits still anywhere, unless he's belted into a moving vehicle or watching very colorful animated musical cartoons), other people at church would still be paying attention to him during the service. Kids are cute and their developmental stages are in a fascinating state of flux. No matter what we do or don't do to "discipline" him, we cannot escape criticism and commentary. If he were shy, more people in the older generation would call him "good" but I'm sure they could also come up with their "concerns" about his social and verbal skills.
Second, not going to church (or as I would prefer, never going back to the mid-week daytime mass with the over-70 crowd) does not exempt my family from judgment. Sure, they would have a quieter service, but we still hear their concerns over whether his "bad behavior" is keeping us away from church. The hypocrisy is amazing, from the choir members who crane their necks in the organ loft to discern whose child is making noise, to the audible comments about our son while we are in the chapel for service. These things do not seem to register as "disruptive" or "irreverent" behavior, as much as they are obviously distracting themselves from worship. . . at this point, my liberal friends are saying, "Why would you even go to this church?"
This leads to my third point. As much as our contemporary generation has been trained to equate tolerance and righteousness, the idea that one could or should choose a church to attend for its universally "welcoming" or "accepting" characteristics is simply impossible and leads to the same level of hypocrisy as my judgmental older friends. I have never been an active member of any organization without encountering (or exhibiting) intolerant behavior. Every group has its own culture, and its own methods for protecting that culture. No matter how liberal or conservative its values, you cannot have a church without some organizational structure, and you cannot have an organizational structure without norms of behavior. Neither can you have a large body of people without it containing individuals with strong and disagreeable opinions.
Yes, I would be upset if these attacks on our parenting abilities were coming from our pastor (they are not, at all), or if another minister involved with leading the service made it seem as though we were expected to punish our toddler as a condition to his attending church (well, hmmm). That would be very hard to accept. However, I see nothing in our faith or practice as a church which makes such unsolicited opinions in any way binding upon our conscience as parishioners. We are doing our best to love and train our child as we should, and there is nothing that we can change at this time except how we choose to respond to others.
That response can only be, forgiveness. It is forgiveness, not sympathetic goals or intellectual agreement, that binds together a family and a community. Forget about generation gaps in church bodies---no grown child would speak to his parents unless he were able to forgive their mistakes in raising him, and their unsolicited advice and unfounded opinions. It is also particularly vital to our Christian religion: we can only enter the church via forgiveness; we are born into Christ through the washing away of our sins in baptism, we live through his life-giving Word, and we are fed His body and blood which is given and shed for us---for the forgiveness of sins. Without an understanding of sin and forgiveness, even the most liberal, universalist congregation cannot tolerate all its members.
Monday, June 01, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Nice post, Emily. Thoughtful, insightful, and well-written. Thanks for sharing it with us.
If it means anything, I empathize.
Besides, you are doing EXACTLY what you should. You are bringing him to church. You are teaching him that it is important. And he is a very sweet, smart, normal little boy.
I'm glad--and impressed--that you're able to look at it this way. We are so glad that you are part of our church family!
Post a Comment